Hello again! Today’s post is my Sopranos review, but before I begin I’d like to give myself more promises to write. I want to do a review of a few Genesis albums, specifically and then there were three... and The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway. I just got both on vinyl, and I’ve actually never heard the former (I got it for a great price), whereas the latter I’ve heard but think it would make for an interesting review. Anyways, with that out of the way, here’s the review. (Contains mild? spoilers, might be more than I think)
It is interesting to note just how much of a risk The Sopranos was at the time. It’s easy to say 26 years on that of course this show would work, but this was a television landscape from before Breaking Bad, Dexter, Game of Thrones, Better Call Saul, and Mad Men. Main characters were not bad people, and TV was a safer medium than film. Whereas film directors could experiment and be “edgy,” meaning to try new, unique things and see where it goes, the furthest TV had gone was Twin Peaks, which was cancelled after two seasons for just getting too insane (and even that show was helmed by a film director). This is to say The Sopranos resembles film in that its a show so willing to experiment, even in its premise: a mob show about the fall of the mob, where the boss is a fat man in therapy.
That premise works wonders, for two reasons. The first is simple: it differentiates it from even the greats of the mob film. Could you imagine Henry Hill or Michael Corleone in therapy? The second is more important to the show: it is a premise that leads to a lot of creative potential. The show uses therapy to look at Tony Soprano’s life as a boss, both of his literal family and mob family, along with his life and relation with his mother, and how these three things interact leading Tony to panic attacks. This is just what the first season does. It’s already a fascinating premise, and the show has the imagination to build on it later.
The first season is one of my favorites of the show. The main conflict of the season is Tony’s relationship with his mother Livia Soprano. That conflict is one of the most well-written conflicts in all of television, and it is one that even when resolved still has effects on its show to its last episode. In short, this isn’t a season one where the show has to find its footing, the show came out the gate swinging. The highlights of this season are Tony’s interactions with his mother, obviously, as well as his therapy sessions with Dr. Melfi. The therapy scenes are absolutely the draw to this show for me: I think it’s less a mob show with therapy than a therapy show with the mob.
The show also does a fantastic job on getting you to Tony’s side in its early episodes. This may seem an odd point to say, as shouldn’t all shows make you like the protagonist? It is important to say for the obvious reason as it is clear even in season one that Tony is not a good person. This fact becomes glaringly apparent as the show goes on (I will highlight it at a certain point especially so), but it is interesting that the show establishes it now. Even if you can see his side, the show doesn’t want you to be with Tony. I think the show even manages that dissonance through the therapy scenes: Melfi serves as a voice of reason and control, to a man who becomes increasingly more dangerous and aggressive as the show, and even the season goes on. I highlight a line from season two, where Melfi argues that “to be a better mob boss, read The Art of War” rather than go to therapy.
After the early death of the boss Jackie Aprile in episode four of the show, Tony gets into a dispute with his uncle Junior Soprano over who will be the next boss of the mob. This dispute forms the other of two conflicts in Tony’s family throughout season one that makes that season so strong: Tony’s fight for control vs. his uncle. This is a very underrated aspect of this season, especially because the rest of the show doesn’t let this tension continue as Junior is put under house arrest and then gets Alzheimer’s in the later seasons. Junior’s older mind and want for control, along with Livia’s manipulation to get control are amazingly written character flaws that create a conflict for Tony throughout the season, and it gets best when the two interact. At the half point of the season, Livia, out of pure hatred for her son’s therapy, manipulates Junior in such a way that Junior orders his assassination.
The assassination is the focus of the season’s penultimate episode, “Isabella,” which I think is one of the finest of the show. It introduces an aspect I absolutely adore, which is Tony’s dreams. His hallucination of Isabella as an ideal maternal figure is a fantastic look at Tony’s mind, and a great introduction to the more surreal aspects of the show seen in Tony’s dreams, which remain a highlight throughout, especially in episodes like “Funhouse” and “The Test Dream” which I will dive into later. The assassination of Tony later in the episode fails, with Tony escaping, in an action sequence that is where I think the show really begins to lock in on its action-oriented sequences. Absolutely fantastic stuff.
What’s crazy about this season, and this show by proxy, is that an episode as great as “Isabella,” which if in almost any other show would be far and away the best of the series, is my 4th favorite. The episodes “College,” “I Dream of Jeanie Cusamano,” and especially “Nobody Knows Anything” are also fantastic episodes that are some of the best ever put on television, while each having its aspects that make it so unique to this show, whether it be the exploration of Tony’s relationship with his daughter and wife in “College”, the culmination of the season’s arcs in “I Dream,” and especially the stress and dread of “Nobody Knows Anything.” That episode is so great I could probably write a blog post just on it. Regardless, season one is not only one of the best debut seasons a show has ever had, but one of my favorite TV seasons of all time. It leaves a fantastic benchmark for the show to go on as it progresses.
I’m not quite sure why I had so much to say on the first season in particular, but this is not to say that the show’s second outing is any worse. The additions of Janice Soprano, Furio, and Bobby Baccala are great for the show, as they are some of the best characters in it. One thing I will say about season two is that while I love the expansion of Tony’s family drama through Janice, and the mob stuff relating to the Italy trip, Junior’s house arrest, and especially Pussy, I think the Richie Aprile storyline is a bit weaker than season one’s conflict of Tony vs. Junior. This is not to say that the Tony/Richie conflict is bad, again! It’s a fantastically written conflict, and I think the resolution of it is a great twist. I just think that it is the weakest part of a season that is otherwise swinging just as hard as its first one.
Season two also ends the what might be the strongest of any season of the show. It’s very close, as I think that seasons 1, 2, 4, 5, and 6 all gun for it, but the 1-2 punch of “The Knight in White Satin Armor” and “Funhouse” is so good. The former’s exploration of Tony’s mistress Irina leads to some of the saddest but best-written scenes in the whole show, and it is paired with the great end to Richie Aprile along with the story of Janice for the season. “Funhouse” is fascinating in that its a true shock the first view: it takes the surrealist dream elements of “Isabella” and cranks them up beyond 11, as Tony’s subconcious is basically screaming at him to confront Pussy. It’s an absolutely thrilling end to the season, as you really do think the action of the season has come to an end, just for the finale to come in and end it all with a bang. The end of Pussy is yet again some of the best writing of the show.
As the show carries on to its third season, I think it starts to face a little bit of an identity crisis; while seasons one and two aren’t necessarily “happy” seasons of television, they are much lighter than what is to come in the latter three seasons of the show. This leaves the third season the role to bridge the two, which it manages well, (this is The Sopranos!) although I do think it to be the weakest season of the show. Part of this may be due to the circumstances around the making of the season: the death of Nancy Marchand meant that the her role for the season had to be cut, which is sad, as Livia testifying against Tony for the Scatino bustout just seems like a dream storyline. But the opening to this season, in the fun “Mr. Ruggerio’s Neighborhood” and “Proshai, Livushka” are something of a new beginning and end to the old times of the show. “Ruggerio’s” sets up the FBI bug of Tony’s house, a plot point which although seemingly insignificant starts what becomes the beginning of the end of the “peaceful” era of the show when said bug is compromised, and “Livushka” ends Livia’s time on the show and her major role in Tony’s life, but leaves her as something of a dark influence over Tony for the rest of the show as he becomes more and more unrecognizable.
This shift in Tony, along with the mob as a whole, is most apparent in the episode “University,” another great one, and one of the darkest of the show. Focusing on both Meadow’s life at Columbia University and the Bada Bing stripper Tracee, this is an episode that really shows the mob at their worst. I mentioned earlier I’d highlight the turning point of Tony’s character, and this is it. It is an episode that reminds you through the dark comedy of the show, these people are irredeemable, more focused on the “disrespecting of the Bing” than Ralphie beating a pregnant 19 year old to death, and how Tony’s sociopathic mind can only empathize with Tracee’s innocence. It is a horrific episode to watch, especially in that ending, but one done so well.
From this point on, The Sopranos shifts from a dark comedy drama about Tony’s life into much more of a deep dive into the evil of the man, and the show becomes much darker. The show shows this literally through its use of color. If you were to watch an episode from seasons 1 and 6 back-to-back, you’ll see a shift to gray. While there may be moments of brevity throughout, like the comedy of Season 3’s “Pine Barrens,” a mostly stand-alone episode that is something of a “comedy of errors,” which I think the show needs every now and then, this is no longer a “fun” show. I think it’s easy to see why “Pine Barrens” is a common favorite Sopranos episode: it’s one of the last fun ones.
As season 3 ends, the other two main storylines are Tony’s relationship with Gloria in his personal life, and Jackie Jr. in his mob life. The Gloria storyline is yet another highlight in a show full of them: the interaction with the borderline personality Gloria are a fantastic continuation of the exploration of Tony’s psyche, and some of the best written and acted scenes in the show. The Jackie Jr. storyline, on the other hand, I feel less strongly on. While I think the plot itself is good, it moves at a very slow pace, but doesn’t go into much depth, so Jackie Jr’s death is not a sad moment, but to me rather one of indifference. It’s one of the few weaknesses in another great season, though.
Season 3 also has a few more essential story beats, like the entire “Employee of the Month” episode, which I will not comment on much to leave unspoiled and not telling Tony is a sad but reasonable decision. In addition, while it is most important to seasons 4 and 5, after the FBI bug on Tony’s house is lost, they decide to flip Adrianna, which is another great story arc, especially in season 5.
Season 4 continues the show getting darker with a more personal season, focused on the relationship of Tony and Carmela. If the draw of the show for you is the personal drama and therapy, this is some of the show’s finest work, but if you’re here for the mob stuff, it is a weaker season. The culmination of the Ralphie storyline is great as always, Joe Pantoliano plays him as such a hilarious but horrible man, but outside of that, the mob stuff isn’t as much a factor. Not that this is a problem, I’ve already said I love this show for the drama, and it’s better than ever. The expansion of Furio’s character and his love of Carmela is an impeccable story, and when Tony and Carmela’s relationship come to a head in “Whitecaps,” it leads to what is quite possibly the best scene in the whole show in Tony and Carmela’s argument.
Season 5 introduces some new characters out of prison, most importantly Steve Buscemi’s Tony Blundetto and Frank Vincent’s Phil Leotardo. I am a huge Steve Buscemi fan, so his addition leads to one of my favorite characters in the show. His attempts at a legitimate life, only to lash out and end up back in the mob life, is a great but heartbreaking story.
Season 5 also happens to have the best 3 episode run in the series, another season-ender. This is why I was unsure if season 2 had the best one, because “The Test Dream,” “Long Term Parking,” and “All Due Respect” are all in my top 10 for the show easily, and probably my top 5 as well, although that one is closer. The first has the finest dream sequence in the whole series, which is probably also my favorite scene in the series. It’s an elaborate, surreal experience that truly showcases the creativity of this show. The second is the most tragic episode of the whole series, and maybe the greatest. I never want to watch it again, though. It’s just too much misery! I can’t take it again! The finale of the season continues this despair in another great culmination to a season, this time the arc of Tony Blundetto. Yet again, great, tragic, and sad stuff. Highly recommend.
If the pure despair of the ending to Soprano’s 5th season wasn’t enough of some of the best TV ever, the 6th keeps this train rolling. The first 3 episodes are a fantastic trilogy I will leave entirely unspoiled. I said too much in this review! But it is at this point that in some ways The Sopranos is largely unrecognizable from that fun dark comedy drama we saw in its first season. The magic of the show is that this works. The show transitioned from one to the other gradually, and both are written equally as well. Especially in the second half (Season 6B, as it’s sometimes called), the show comes to a fantastic end. “Soprano Home Movies” feels like one last moment of brevity, yet even that one gets intense as Tony and Bobby fight, and from that point on, the show marches on to a dark but phenomenal ending. That final run of “Kennedy and Heidi” to “Made In America” is some of the best of the show. My only complaint is that the end of the Melfi storyline, while I like in concept, feels way too rushed. If it was built up across all of season 6, I think it would work better. As is, it feels sudden that it all really goes down in a single episode. Although that single episode, “The Blue Comet,” is so good. The escalation of Tony and Phil’s conflict, and the ensuing bloodshed is amazing, and it almost all comes together in “Made in America,” a finale which addresses everything, and leaves one last mystery for the road in its final shot.
Yeah, it’s The Sopranos. It’s not insane to say it’s good. But the blending of comedy and drama, and the shift of those elements as it goes on, along with the focuses on how the show exemplifies these two elements is to me what creates such a great show.
Overall: Would Recommend
Thank you for reading this post! It was a bigger one, I think the biggest I’ve done by a large margin. Have a fantastic rest of your day.